No. 10 - Shapley/Curtis debate

 
Back in 1920, when it happened, this debate was so big that astronomers know it simply as "the Great Debate." And, like a political debate, this one happened on a single day, with a room full of people.

The Smithsonian Institution was the host for the debate, with Harlow Shapley arguing that the Milky Way galaxy was the center of the universe, with all other galaxies a part of the Milky Way; Heber Curtis, on the other hand, believed the Milky Way was just one of many galaxies.

Nowadays, sixth-grade students and anyone who's ever watched a planetarium show knows that Curtis was more right about the nature of our universe...but Shapley may have been more right about the nature of our galaxy, placing our sun at the outskirts of the Milky Way, while Curtis placed it dead center. It's nice when everyone gets to say they were right about something.

Top 10 Science Feuds    10   9   8   7   6   5   4   3   2   1    Next »

More Top 10s

piltdown Top 10 Science Hoaxes
You might know about Piltdown Man, but what about the deadly cake?
mad scientist Top 10 Mad Scientists
The original Dr. Evil.
mating Top 10 Mating Rituals
No gin fizzes necessary!
deadliest, diseases Top 10 Deadly Diseases
What are the most common, but deadliest, diseases?
organs Top 10 Useless Body Parts
Anyone who's had a wisdom tooth pulled will know what we mean.
accidental inventions Top 10 Accidental Inventions
When whoops! really works out for the best.
 
 
advertisement

Shop Science Channel

 
newsletter
 
 

our sites

video

shop

stay connected

corporate